Monday, January 3

My Light Rail Rant

Wes Flynn's blog is a veritable hotbed of light-rail/mass transit wishful thinking, all because of this guest column in the Enquirer.

Some of the discussion revolves around what people in the suburbs think of mass transit, and it's been suggested that they're afraid of the "inner city" criminal element using public transportation to prey upon the outlying areas.

Maybe there are people who think this; maybe there aren't. But as an ex-exurbanite, I'm inclined to think that any suburban opposition to mass transit (and here I'm thinking particularly of light rail) is based less on suburban fear and more on suburban architecture.

When I lived in Milford, I was opposed to light rail - not because of crime, but because I couldn't see the point.

Outer-belt suburbs are planned around the assumption that people want to drive everywhere; everything is spaced far apart, there are hardly any sidewalks, and there's tons of free parking everywhere. And I lived in one from middle school until just last year. I was indocrinated in the ways of the suburbanite. Why, I thought as a young retail worker, would I want to take mass transit from my home in Milford to my job in Kenwood Towne Centre? Why, I wondered, would anyone want to spend good money on something no one would use, since everyone drives everywhere anyway?

Not only that, but if light rail came to Milford, I knew it would only venture as far as the "downtown" neighborhood; I didn't even live in Milford, but rather the "suburbs" of this suburb. I'd still have to drive to the rail stop - just as, had I ever tried to take the Metro, I would have found it necessary to drive to the bus stop.

That was then.

Now, as someone who lives in the city and works downtown, I get it, all right? I totally get the point of not having to worry about buying a parking pass each month for a lot that I don't feel safe walking to at night, not getting stuck in traffic on the way to and from work, not having to worry about where in Mount Lookout Square to park because it's just a teensy bit too far to walk in these shoes, not having to play the infernal duck-duck-goose game of "So, who's going to be designated driver?"

Cities were designed for walking, horses and (yes) mass transit. Suburbs were designed for cars. But I didn't know that before, because I had never lived in a city.

Anyway, mine is only one experience, but it was a point I hadn't seen mentioned in the discussion, so I thought I'd share. Now if you'll excuse me, the group in my office who walks to the parking lot together is leaving.

3 Comments:

At 12:17 AM, Wes said...

Thanks for the link!

As I mentioned in my update, check out Suburban Nation by Duany, Plater-Zyberk, and Speck. It addresses some of the things you talked about with regard to layout of the 'burbs.

WF

 
At 6:35 PM, Anonymous said...

Typical amerikan suburban shopping mall pig....

 
At 6:48 PM, Anonymous said...

One of the reasons we can't convince everyone to believe in the powers of mass transit is b/c it's too easy to get around in this city. If you were forced to live in the suburbs 30+ miles from the city due to economy, schools, job, etc. and traffic was a nightmare, you would use the light rail to travel to different places. Unfortunately (b/c I'm a light rail supporter), this town is not "big" enough.

I visited Denver over the holidays. Development has boomed in this western city over the past decade. The numbers are staggering. My wife's parents live 45 minutes (on a good day) from downtown. Traffic crawls on a daily basis. In this situation, light rail makes sense, and is used by the mass public. I believe the projected future totals for usage were achieved in the first year of operation.

I don't think this city has the sheer numbers to support it, but I'm for it if the vote comes around again.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home


CIN WEEKLY BLOGS
Popography
Soundcheck
Pig blog - Emily and Lindsey
Pig blog - Dean
Pig blog - Ben
More Cincinnati.Com Blogs

THE LAST WORD
Have the last word. For real. In CiN. Submit an editorial and get your name in print.
Read the latest one
Submit your thoughts

YOU TELL US
Every week, CiN wants to get the answers from our readers. Tell us what you think.
You Tell Us

DEAR DOUG
Ask Doug your burning questions about relationships, getting ahead and the world in general.
Ask Dear Doug

BAR GUIDE
Over 500 bars from the area listed. You should be able to find somewhere to head to this week.
CiN Weekly Bar Guide

DINING GUIDE
Use our Cincinnati.Com restaurant search to find information about more than 1,000 area eateries.
CiN Weekly Dining Guide

SUBMIT!
Do you know of something CiN should cover in an upcoming issue? Just let us know.
Submit your ideas
Submit an event